Geoscience Policy Monthly Review
november 2014
The Monthly Review is part of a continuing effort to improve communications about the role of geoscience in policy.
Current and archived monthly reviews are available online.Subscribe to receive the Monthly Review directly.
natural resources
Keystone XL Pipeline bill falls one vote short of passage in Senate
November 18, 2014
A bill to approve the TransCanada Keystone XL pipeline project failed to pass the U.S. Senate by a single vote on November 18. The project currently transfers oil from sources in the Western Canadian Sedimentary Basin in Alberta, Canada to refineries in Illinois, Oklahoma, and Texas. Had it passed, the Northern Route Approval Act (H.R. 3) would have approved construction of a new section of pipeline from Hardisty, Alberta to Steele City, Nebraska, which would both shorten the pipeline route and allow shipments to include light crude oil from the Bakken formation of Montana and North Dakota.
Proponents of the bill argued that the project would contribute to economic gains and job growth and that heavy oil from Alberta will likely be used regardless of the pipeline approval. They also emphasized that alternate shipping methods, including rail, barge, or truck, are expensive, produce greenhouse gas emissions and are more prone to accidents and spills than a pipeline. Republican lawmakers have pledged to renew efforts to pass the bill when the new Congress convenes in January.
An environmental impact statement released earlier this year by the State Department found that the project would not have a significant impact on greenhouse gas emissions, since oil production in Alberta will likely continue whether the pipeline is built or not. However, critics of the bill argue that extracting crude from oil sands results in higher emissions than other extraction techniques and that construction of the project would set a precedent for opening unconventional resources to exploitation.
Sources: E&E News, Roll Call News
Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee holds markup on energy, parks, and lands bills
November 13, 2014
On November 13, the Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee held a markup of 16 bills pertaining to energy, parks, and public lands. Of the 16 bills, 12 were passed out of committee by a voice vote, addressing wilderness designations, grazing management issues, and historic site protections. Four bills underwent further discussion before passing, three by roll call vote and one by voice vote.
The National Park Access Act (S. 2104) would authorize the National Park Service (NPS) to reimburse states for money spent keeping parks and forests open during the 2013 government shutdown, and it was passed by a voice vote. A related bill, the Public Access to Public Land Guarantee Act (S. 1750), would institute a standing agreement for continued operation of parks and forests in the case of future shutdowns. Despite reservations expressed by several Democrats, the bill narrowly passed by a roll call vote of 12-10.
These bills have been recognized as examples of effective bipartisan compromise, balancing the interests of conservationists with those of ranchers, loggers, and other public lands stakeholders.
Sources: Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee website